PureSchmaltz

Rendered Fat Content

Cruelity

cruelty
Charles Meryon:
The Vampire
(1853)


“…there was never, under any condition, the freedom to commit Cruelty without grave consequences, without well-deserved Comeuppances. Ours has arrived with his.”


It was never true that anything might be possible if we merely eliminated limits, for limitations deliver much more than restraints. By designating boundaries, they help define both context and content, which seem absolutely necessary for identity. History has tried to teach us that context colors the quality of any content, and effort attempted without explicit regulation ultimately smothers progress. In theory, the Cruelty of any strategy shouldn’t matter, especially if it’s used as a means to achieve some higher end state, under the “You Have To Break Some Eggs To Create An Omelet” Theory of Human Development, for instance. In practice, employing Cruelty has ultimately always perverted the result, eliminating the possibility of ever achieving that aspired-to higher end state.

Even ignoring the likelihood of karma taking her toll, Cruelty creates an unresolvable paradox out of a situation.
In the case of our incumbent, he might have been born to clearly demonstrate that one cannot achieve any greatness, and especially greatness again, by means of employing Cruelty. Greatness might require higher means than anything from the lower end of the means spectrum, where Cruelty lurks. The Nazis clearly demonstrated the folly of believing in such things as a master race, and probably the folly of even believing meaningful differences exist between races. Their attempts to segregate their society into worthy and unworthy left them with a disturbing surplus of self-designated worthless resources in desperate need of disposal. Slave labor or death camps were two apparently logical resolutions for their self-imposed problem, both of which could only have been contemplated as long as Cruelty remained on the table.

I fear the once-reliable Nazi example has grown shopworn and toothless over the last three-quarters of a century. I fear more the sense of complicity implicit whenever our President employs Cruelty in public policy. Cruelty was the signature component of the twisted vision he shared as a candidate for office. In his first term, he reveled in belittling those least able to fend for themselves, as if this were not a commonwealth and he was not equally responsible for everybody’s well-being, not just the wealthy and landed gentry. Cruelty became an implicit part of seemingly every policy, as if he were settling scores with some force that had suppressed him before. He was never once the victim of anything more than his own hand, though his hand had reliably betrayed him. He seemed to behave as if he believed that if he could only be sufficiently cruel to others, he might take less advantage of himself.

The primary reason we can’t tolerate having a king lies in our founding belief that we were all created equal. Cruelty requires the presence of a king, someone designated unaccountably powerful enough to deploy Cruelty if he feels he needs to. Equality leaves no space for Cruelty toward anybody. It justifies no omissions, insisting upon itself under the law. Nothing can rightly justify cruelty in any society that truly believes itself a collection of peers. There, But For Fortune applies equally to everybody, rendering nobody beneath compassion or above contempt. Cruelty seems like an equal opportunity crime, begging for a fair and balanced response. Deploying Cruelty seems the equivalent of begging for Cruelty in return, a circular, self-fulfilling punishment cycle that should serve as adequate discouragement from ever engaging in it. It doesn’t.

What happened to us? Was it the wholesale sacking of our economy? The denial of advancement for most of our once-dominant middle class? Did we come to worship mammon? What made our incumbent’s inherent Cruelty attractive enough for most to at least overlook the obvious ramifications and vote him in? Did a majority really believe that he could suspend any of the iron-clad rules governing governance to successfully deploy Cruelty as his primary policy imperative, and that that might make anything or anyone greater as a result? I cannot believe it. MAGA was never more or less than a mania, hopefully temporary, where Cruelty became the dominant policy, to produce nothing more or less than the usual paradox, predictable, truly terrible consequences. Sometimes there were free lunches, but there was never, under any condition, the freedom to commit Cruelty without grave consequences, without well-deserved Comeuppances. Ours has arrived with his.

©2026 by David A. Schmaltz - all rights reserved






blog comments powered by Disqus

Made in RapidWeaver